Next: Comparison with Other Studies
Up: Radial Velocity Zero-Point Errors
Previous: Analysis of LWP Camera
Because wavelengths were measured individually for more than 700 lines in
the 10 Lac atlas, it was possible to search for wavelength errors as a function
of wavelength in both the GHRS and IUE/SWP data for 10 Lac.
Figure 12 depicts (small crosses)
the differences between the laboratory lines
referred to in the Brandt et al. (1998) study and the measurements they made
from their atlas lines (these differences have been corrected for the radial
velocity of the star). We also plot as a solid line the cross-correlation
results between the GHRS atlas and ensemble of SWP IUE
spectra at each SWP-order bin (cf. Fig. 9).
This line shows mean fluctuations of
± 3 km s-1. Its
excursions from zero are always less than
± 3 km s-1. From
these results we conclude that there are no significant differences between
the wavelengths of the GHRS and SWP camera. To some degree, this
is not unexpected because both calibrations were made using
the same line list. Even so, the calibrations were derived
using different algorithms. In particular, the GHRS wavelength
solutions were obtained by a block-grouping of lines in the entire spectral
domain (Lindler 1993) whereas the IUE solutions were performed for
individual echelle orders for wavelengths greater than 1350.
Figure 12 shows no trend in the mean velocities
for echelle orders grouped above and below the 1350 demarcation.
We can expect that both random and systematic errors of the more current
Pt wavelengths
are smaller than the older, heterogeneous sources. For example, one may
attribute the increased scatter of points in this figure below 1500
to random errors from the older laboratory studies. Similarly, any
systematic errors in the older laboratory data would show up
as trends away from both the zero-level and the solid line.
The dashed line in the plot shows evidence of possible systematics in the
laboratory data in the wavelength range
1650-1750 and
1190-1250. Detailed inspection of the line list from
which the GHRS wavelengths are drawn suggests that such descrepancies
are not limited to one type of ion. For example, several ions of both light
and Fe-like ions are represented in these wavelength regions.
Next: Comparison with Other Studies
Up: Radial Velocity Zero-Point Errors
Previous: Analysis of LWP Camera
8/17/2001